editors
3,524
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 4:
Line 4: − + − + + + + + + + + + + +
no edit summary
I would for example add {{P|27}} and {{Q|1117}} as qualifiers typically added under {{P|10}}. Thoughts {{reply_to|Podehaye}} {{reply_to|Hanz0mon}}? -- [[User:Alexbfree|Alexbfree]] ([[User talk:Alexbfree|talk]]) 15:47, 11 February 2020 (UTC)
I would for example add {{P|27}} and {{Q|1117}} as qualifiers typically added under {{P|10}}. Thoughts {{reply_to|Podehaye}} {{reply_to|Hanz0mon}}? -- [[User:Alexbfree|Alexbfree]] ([[User talk:Alexbfree|talk]]) 15:47, 11 February 2020 (UTC)
: {{reply_to|Alexbfree}} yes, we should seek to extend this technique to have the expressivity you are seeking with the page [[Project:Vocabulary/GDPR]]. one comment though: you use {{Q|1117}} as a qualifier, but I think you mean a property, no? (also on [[Project:Vocabulary/GDPR]]). [[User:Podehaye|Podehaye]] ([[User talk:Podehaye|talk]]) 16:24, 11 February 2020 (UTC)
: {{reply_to|Alexbfree}} yes, we should seek to extend this technique to have the expressivity you are seeking with the page [[Project:Vocabulary/GDPR]].
:: {{reply_to|Podehaye}} erm, well, it is showing the source of this specific {{P|10}}-snak, so I think that makes it a qualifier, right? A property, that is being used as a qualifier? I think some properties (such as {{Q|1048}}) could apply either as a qualifier on a snak or as a property on an Item - whereas some properties like {{Q|1117}} would apply typically only as a qualifier upon a snak. Right? If I am using concepts incorrectly, please let me know - it's certainly possible I have the wrong mental model!
== discussion about {{Q|1117}} ==
one comment though: you use {{Q|1117}} as a qualifier, but I think you mean a property, no? (also on [[Project:Vocabulary/GDPR]]). [[User:Podehaye|Podehaye]] ([[User talk:Podehaye|talk]]) 16:24, 11 February 2020 (UTC)
:: {{reply_to|Podehaye}} erm, well, it is showing the source of this specific {{P|10}}-snak, so I think that makes it a qualifier, right? A property, that is being used as a qualifier? I think some properties (such as {{Q|1048}}) could apply either as a qualifier on a snak or as a property on an Item - whereas some properties like {{Q|1117}} would apply typically only as a qualifier upon a snak. Right? If I am using concepts incorrectly, please let me know - it's certainly possible I have the wrong mental model! [[User:Alexbfree|Alexbfree]] ([[User talk:Alexbfree|talk]]) 17:00, 11 February 2020 (UTC)
:: {{reply_to|Podehaye}} Let me check I got this right:
* Snak = Property + Value (where value could be an Item, Property, text or something else).
* A snak directly upon an Item could be considered a property of that Item (a 'property snak', let's say)
* A qualifier would be a snak applied to a 'property snak'. A property of an Item property.
Is this right? [[User:Alexbfree|Alexbfree]] ([[User talk:Alexbfree|talk]]) 17:00, 11 February 2020 (UTC)